|
VoIP Articles Professionals |
|
|
H.323 and SIP - VoIP Protocols Comparison

In recent years, the internet technology has grown in leaps and bounds. One major product of this technology is the Voice over Internet protocol (VoIP). VoIP is a technology that enables better audio and visual communication from our home computers. Through this, we can communicate easily from wherever we are and it is cheaper than the conventional telephone services. The upfront investment required for this is also very less. VOIP is still in its early stages and it has to undergo more development before it can substitute the regular telephone.
The two types of VOIP protocols used today are:
1. H.323 2. SIP
H.323
The more commonly used protocol. This was created by the International Telecommunication Union for the purposes of multimedia communication over IP networks.
It provides provisions for videoconferencing, data sharing, and audio transmission (VoIP)
It merges the IETF and ITU-T protocols to form a unified system
Though it is still in the early phases, it has been successful to some extent in matching the clarity and speed provided by PSTN networks
USES OF H.323
Videoconferencing
Voice over IP
It is been designed with a number of means to recover connection failures. It has a number of alternate gatekeepers and endpoints which help to pinpoint the source of connection failure.
H.323 performs a lot of functions like:
Message encoding
Load balancing
Call signaling
Address resolution
In the message encoding process, messages are encoded by H.323 into binary format and are decoded by using decoding machines. This binary format is suitable for both broadband and narrow band connections.
In load balancing process, endpoints report their total and available capacity to H.323, which distributes the calls equally across these gateways.
In call signaling process, the H.323 gatekeeper provides address resolution through RAS message exchange and routes the call signaling traffic.
In address resolution, the H.323 gatekeeper may use any number of protocols to discover the destination address of the callee, including LRQs to other gatekeepers, Annex G/H.225.0, TRIP, ENUM, and/or DNS.
New features are added to H.323 keeping in mind that backward compatibility is preserved.
SIP
The second type of VOIP protocol used is the SIP.
SIP was designed to setup a session between two points
It has no support for multimedia conferencing
SIP has large number of problems and has been deployed successfully only in PSTN gateways
Detection can only be done through timer expiration and re-establishment takes long periods
Like H.323, SIP also performs the functions of message encoding, load balancing, and address resolution.
In message coding, the message are coded into ASCII format and are too long. This makes it suitable only for broadband networks. Efforts are being made to encode SIP in binary format.
In the load balancing stage, SIP follows trial and error methods across different proxy servers available. If there is a timeout, then it shifts to another server.
In the process of address resolution, SIP has no address-resolution protocol.
DISADVANTAGES OF SIP
The main disadvantage of SIP is that it has no means to detect network failures
The processing requirements placed on the SIP proxy are higher than with H.323, which requires more message exchanges to pinpoint the position
Another main problem with SIP is that all the new versions are not backward compatible, which causes operational problems
Hence we see that in many ways, H.323 protocol is vertical and complex, but actually SIP is horizontal and more open. So SIP protocol pretends to be more promising, despite of disadvantages.
By Andrey J. Kanevsky
|
|
|
|
VoIP Providers List Information |
|
|
|
If you have any constructive thoughts, creative ideas, or reasonable offers, please, contact us.
|
|
Send Email to Helen O'Neill if you have any questions either about this website, or about VoIP providers, or VoIP in general.
|
|
Send Email to our technical support if you have any technical queries.
|
About VoIP Providers List
VoIP Providers List services save time for companies searching both for information and interconnection partners, interested in voice minutes exchange, i.e. VoIP minutes termination and origination, as well as hardware and software trade. We provide information on interconnection services, VoIP hardware solutions and VoIP software , as well as overall situation in the VoIP industry.
VoIP Providers List is constantly moderated, and thus we can guarantee that any VoIP provider published in the web-based company catalogue has provided accurate details on its services and operations.
We are constantly working on improvement and development of our services. Your comments and proposals regarding the services are highly welcome. Please, do not hesitate to contact us providing with your ideas, opinion, and feed-back. We will be grateful for any information and useful links on Voice over IP, VoIP hardware, VoIP software, and VoIP Providers.
|
|
|
|
|
VoIP Providers Statistics |
|
|
Providers in database: 3315
Users Online: 376
|
|
|