|
|
Verizon ruling threatens all VoIP companies claim
2007-04-18
Two of the three Verizon patents a jury upheld in a March decision were described in a standards group called the VoIP Forum before Verizon filed for the patents, said Daniel Berninger, who had a hand in launching Vonage but now works as a telecom analyst for Tier 1 Research.
The VoIP Forum described the name translation call-processing step in an open standard developed in 1996, and Verizon applied for the two patents in March 1997 and February 2000, he said.
Verizon's patents focus on using name translation to connect VoIP calls to traditional telephone networks. But without name translation, no VoIP calls could be completed, and all VoIP companies are in danger of getting sued, Berninger said. "If you translate these patents so ridiculously broadly, then there's nothing left," he said. "Everybody infringes."
Two Verizon spokesmen didn't immediately respond to a request for comments on Berninger's information.
Berninger, an advocate of open standards and co-founder of the VON Coalition, said members of the VoIP Forum talked extensively about name translation during call set-up discussions about the voice portion of the H.323 standard during 1996, and in the parallel development of the Session Initiation Protocol (SIP) at the Internet Engineering Task Force. Several major tech vendors participated in the standards-setting process, and two papers on H.323 published in January 1997, one by co-workers at his former employer VocalTec, describe the technologies later patented by Verizon, he said.
Other telecom experts, however, have disagreed about whether Verizon's patents could affect other VoIP providers.
But Berninger compared name translation to the Internet's domain name system (DNS), which translates domain names into IP addresses. "Essentially every VoIP provider on planet Earth" uses the name translation processing step, he said.
Vonage pointed to other technology it believed preceded Verizon's patents at a trial that ended with a March verdict that the company had infringed three Verizon patents. A Virginia court interpreted the Verizon claims too broadly to be valid, said Brooke Schulz, Vonage's vice president for communications
"The patents as filed and awarded ... were very narrow," she said. "We continue to believe, for this and many other reasons, we don't infringe on their technology."
Berninger began looking into the patents recently because of the Vonage case. In the March verdict, Vonage was ordered to pay Verizon $ 58 million. Last Friday, a US judge barred Vonage from signing up new customers, but an appeals court gave the company a temporary stay the same day.
By Grant Gross
|
|
|
|
VoIP Providers List Information |
|
|
|
If you have any constructive thoughts, creative ideas, or reasonable offers, please, contact us.
|
|
Send Email to Helen O'Neill if you have any questions either about this website, or about VoIP providers, or VoIP in general.
|
|
Send Email to our technical support if you have any technical queries.
|
About VoIP Providers List
VoIP Providers List services save time for companies searching both for information and interconnection partners, interested in voice minutes exchange, i.e. VoIP minutes termination and origination, as well as hardware and software trade. We provide information on interconnection services, VoIP hardware solutions and VoIP software , as well as overall situation in the VoIP industry.
VoIP Providers List is constantly moderated, and thus we can guarantee that any VoIP provider published in the web-based company catalogue has provided accurate details on its services and operations.
We are constantly working on improvement and development of our services. Your comments and proposals regarding the services are highly welcome. Please, do not hesitate to contact us providing with your ideas, opinion, and feed-back. We will be grateful for any information and useful links on Voice over IP, VoIP hardware, VoIP software, and VoIP Providers. |
|
|
|
|
VoIP Providers Statistics |
|
|
Providers in database: 3315
Users Online: 278
|
|
|
